Adverse events database not useful for drawing safety conclusions, expert says

Loading the player...

The carte blanche release of adverse events data could give a skewed view of the safety of the dietary supplement industry, one expert says.

Adverse event reports have been part of the dietary supplement industry since 2007.  But what’s new this year is the Food and Drug Administration’s decision to make the data within these files public, something that was done in late 2016.  Rick Kingston, PharmD, a professor of clinical pharmacy with the University of Minnesota. said that the way that has been done gives the impression there is useful information to be gleaned from these files, which in their raw form is simply not the case.

Kingston said that the way their adverse events are entered into the data base conforms to the letter of the law.  But it does not represent a very useable data set. Too much information is missing, and much of what is there is too imprecise.  For example, a consumer might complain that they had chest pain after taking a particular supplement, but decline to be more specific about what kind of pain they experienced.  Was it a true cardiac event?  Heart burn?  Something else?  They might also indicate that they were treated for the complaint but decline to provide information about what kind of treatment or about what the attending physician had to say about the situation. This particular example might entered using standard medical codes as a case of angina, a potentially serious complaint.

Noise clouds signal

“When you look at the events that come in it’s really only about 5% or maybe 6% that signal something that needs to be looked at, Kingston said.  Kingston, who is President, Regulatory and Scientific Affairs at SafetyCall International, spoke with NutraIngredients-USA at the 17th Annual Oxford Conference on the Science of Botanicals put on by National Center for Natural Products Research at the University of Mississippi.  The conference wrapped up on April 6.

Despite the shortcomings of the system, Kingston said it is still a very valuable tool for responsible companies when treated with the proper filters, so to speak.

“The best practice companies actually do analyze their adverse events experience to get a good handle on those types of events that they really need to take a closer look at and the events that are more likely representative of the background noise that you get in all spontaneously reported adverse event management,he said.

Kingston said FDA released some but not all of the data associated with each adverse event report in an attempt to be more transparent to the public.  But without the narrative associated with the event (information that FDA chose not to release), Kingston said it’s hard to get a handle on exactly what role the supplement or ingredient played in the event.

“I don’t think anybody can look at that data set and draw any conclusions. It’s just not amenable to that type of analysis, Kingston said.

For more information on what was on the agenda in Oxford, click here.

Related News

© iStock

FDA releases adverse events data for supplements, foods, and cosmetics

The Toxicology Forum met at the St. Regis Hotel in Aspen.

Complexity of supplements hampers adverse events reporting, experts say

Interest in adverse event reporting post AG probe up 15-20%, say experts

Interest in adverse event reporting post AG probe up 15-20%, say experts

“Instead of waiting for and reacting to product safety issues, the industry must embrace pro-active best practices from other industries and adapt them.” - Dr Stephen Schmitz from Supplement Safety Solutions

Nutravigilance program marks ‘the beginning of a new era of adverse event reporting’

While smaller players have attempted to attract younger consumers, 5-hour Energy’s success has been in large part down to its ability to appeal to office workers and older consumers trying to stay alert, say experts

5-Hour Energy: Adverse event reports do not prove that our shots caused 13 deaths

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.