DISPATCHES FROM VITAFOODS EUROPE 2014

Natural and synthetic astaxanthin are different products, Algatech exec says

Loading the player...

The natural vs synthetic astaxanthin debate centers on the fact that the products are not strictly analogous. “We are not saying that natural is necessarily better.  We are saying it’s different,” said Efrat Kat, director of marketing and sales for Algatechnologies.

“The name might be the same, but everything else is completely different,” Kat told NutraIngredients-USA at the recent Vitafoods trade show in Geneva, Switzerland.  

Algatech, as the company is also known, is an algae producer based in Israel’s southern desert, and is one of the founding members of NAXA, the Natural Astaxanthin Association.  Kat said the difference in the makeup of the natural vs synthetic ingredients has to do with the different isomers of the molecule present in both forms and in the other components of the final product, which in the case of the natural producers consists primarily of other carotenoids.  “For the synthetic, we don’t know what it is,” Kat said.

Also, the differences in the forms means that in the opinion of the natural producers, any evidence of health benefits applies to their ingredients alone, Kat said. The efficacy studies that have been done up to this point have been done using natural astaxanthin. “This is the most important point for us. We believe the health benefits need to be proved,” she said.

One of the arguments put forward in favor of synthetic production is that the process can be rigidly controlled, yielding a consistent product.  Kat says this argument doesn't apply for Algatech, as they use a closed tube system for their algae cultivation. "We are in a desert environment, using solar radiation, and it is very consistent in different times of the year.  We are cultivating our micro algae in a closed system and we are controlling all the parameters. Everything that goes in and everything that comes out," she said.

Related News

The joint venture plant in Japan will be based on Heliae's existing facility, above, in Gilbert, a southeastern suburb of Phoenix.

Heliae enters joint venture to produce astaxanthin in Japan via hybrid algal technology

What does 'natural' mean when applied to a food or a supplement? The new Organic and Natural Health Alliance aims to find out.

New trade organization forms with mission to define what 'natural' means

The use of thin-walled tubes will help boost astaxanthin output at Algatech's facility in southern Israel.  The R&D deal is part of the company's plan to double production.

Algatech enters deal to boost astaxanthin production with thin-walled tubes

Cyanotech expands astaxanthin market share, moves toward fully integrated production

Cyanotech expands astaxanthin market share, moves toward fully integrated production

New leader Steinford says NAXA will broaden mission from ingredient defense to market expansion

New leader Steinford says NAXA will broaden mission from ingredient defense to market expansion

Valensa makes more astaxanthin as eye health demand increases

Astaxanthin eyed as weight loss ingredient

DSM supplies a number of carotenoids, including its synthetic form of astaxanthin called AstaSana.

DSM elbows into astaxanthin market with synthetic ingredient

Algatchnologies' production base in southern Israel

Israeli player launches 2% water soluble astaxanthin

Related Products

See more related products